Locked
Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ
Annie Fisher <afisher@...>

Greetings,
Join us for a technical community discussion of the Akraino Edge Stack Project. This 1.5 day event will feature sessions on blueprints, seed code, architecture and more. Don't miss the opportunity to meet with fellow community members and help define the project roadmap!
Event Details: Akraino Edge Stack Project Developer Summit Date: Thursday, August 23rd, registration starting at 8:00 a.m., Friday, August 24th, half day (full schedule to follow) Where: AT&T Labs Research, Building A, 200 Laurel Avenue South, Middletown, New Jersey, 07748
PLEASE NOTE: Registration is limited to 5 participants per company.
To Register: Please visit our Registration Site or check out our Event Website for information on the area, parking, etc.
Thank you and we look forward to seeing you there.
|
| |
Annie Fisher, MPA CSM
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
|
|
Locked
Re: Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ
Margaret Chiosi <margaret.chiosi1@...>
Great – I can’t attend. It is the same week as ACM sigcomm in Budapest.
I know wenjing can attend. Let me see if it is ok to have someone else also attend with him.
And I live in NJ! Oh well.
Do you know when there will be weekly calls?
Thank You,
Margaret Chiosi
VP Open Ecosystem Team
Admin: Sophie Johnson
Sophie.johnson1@...
+1 (908) 541-3590
Futurewei Technologies, Inc.
Fixed Network Solution CC
400 Crossing Blvd
Bridgewater, NJ 08807
(cell) +1-732-216-5507

toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
From: main@... [mailto:main@...]
On Behalf Of Annie Fisher
Sent: Tuesday, August 07, 2018 5:10 PM
To: main@...
Subject: [akraino] Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ

Greetings,
Join us for a technical community discussion of the Akraino Edge Stack Project. This 1.5 day event will feature sessions on blueprints, seed code, architecture and more. Don't miss the opportunity
to meet with fellow community members and help define the project roadmap!
Event Details: Akraino Edge Stack Project Developer Summit
Date: Thursday, August 23rd, registration starting at 8:00 a.m., Friday, August 24th, half day (full schedule to follow)
Where: AT&T Labs Research, Building A, 200
Laurel Avenue South, Middletown, New Jersey, 07748
PLEASE NOTE: Registration is limited to 5 participants per company.
To Register: Please visit our Registration Site or check out our Event
Website for information on the area, parking, etc.
Thank you and we look forward to seeing you there.
|
|
|
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation
Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
|
|
Locked
Re: Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ
Annie Fisher <afisher@...>
We will miss you at the event, Margaret! The date for the TSC meeting series will be coming out soon. Will make sure you're on the calendar invite.
Cheers, Annie Annie Fisher, MPA CSM
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Great – I can’t attend. It is the same week as ACM sigcomm in Budapest.
I know wenjing can attend. Let me see if it is ok to have someone else also attend with him.
And I live in NJ! Oh well.
Do you know when there will be weekly calls?
Thank You,
Margaret Chiosi
VP Open Ecosystem Team
Admin: Sophie Johnson
Sophie.johnson1@...
+1 (908) 541-3590
Futurewei Technologies, Inc.
Fixed Network Solution CC
400 Crossing Blvd
Bridgewater, NJ 08807
(cell) +1-732-216-5507
From: main@... [mailto:main@...]
On Behalf Of Annie Fisher
Sent: Tuesday, August 07, 2018 5:10 PM
To: main@...
Subject: [akraino] Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ

Greetings,
Join us for a technical community discussion of the Akraino Edge Stack Project. This 1.5 day event will feature sessions on blueprints, seed code, architecture and more. Don't miss the opportunity
to meet with fellow community members and help define the project roadmap!
Event Details: Akraino Edge Stack Project Developer Summit
Date: Thursday, August 23rd, registration starting at 8:00 a.m., Friday, August 24th, half day (full schedule to follow)
Where: AT&T Labs Research, Building A, 200
Laurel Avenue South, Middletown, New Jersey, 07748
PLEASE NOTE: Registration is limited to 5 participants per company.
To Register: Please visit our Registration Site or check out our Event
Website for information on the area, parking, etc.
Thank you and we look forward to seeing you there.
|
|
|
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation
Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
|
|
Locked
Re: Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ
Annie Fisher <afisher@...>
Greetings Tianji,
Thank you for your email. We'd love to have you at the event and have fixed the registration page, so please register now for the event.
Cheers, Annie Annie Fisher, MPA CSM
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Hello, I am Tianji Jiang from the China Mobile Research, located in Milpitas, CA. Our team have been doing R&D on the edge-computing area and closely watching the progress of the AKRAINO project. I just learned this meeting scheduled in AT&T lab on this coming Thursday/Friday (08/23, 08/24) from my colleague in China Mobile. I am very interested and want to attend the meeting. However, when I went to the registration website, it is showing the registration is full currently. So, I am directly writing this email to your attention and hope you could help me register for the meeting. As you may know, as the largest mobile provider in the world (close to ~ 930 Million subscribers), we China Mobile are very committed to the edge-computing. Further, my colleagues have attended the AKRAINO meeting scheduled in Oregon Intel campus in this past May (2018/05). One of my team mates has registered for this week’s AKRAINO meeting in AT&T, and we want to attend together. Both of us are in the Silicon Valley and actively working in the edge-computing area. Given the more popularity and attraction of the AKRAINO project in edge-computing, we want to explore further the progress of the project so that we can participate more actively in the community. Thank you in advance for the registration help. Regards, -Tianji From: Jiajin Gao <jiajingao@...> Date: Monday, August 20, 2018 at 11:53 AM To: 'Tianji Jiang' <tianjijiang@...> Subject: FW: [akraino] Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ FYI. From: main@... [mailto:main@...] On Behalf Of Annie Fisher Sent: Tuesday, August 07, 2018 5:10 PM To: main@... Subject: [akraino] Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ 
Greetings,
Join us for a technical community discussion of the Akraino Edge Stack Project. This 1.5 day event will feature sessions on blueprints, seed code, architecture and more. Don't miss the opportunity to meet with fellow community members and help define the project roadmap!
Event Details: Akraino Edge Stack Project Developer Summit Date: Thursday, August 23rd, registration starting at 8:00 a.m., Friday, August 24th, half day (full schedule to follow) Where: AT&T Labs Research, Building A, 200 Laurel Avenue South, Middletown, New Jersey, 07748
PLEASE NOTE: Registration is limited to 5 participants per company.
To Register: Please visit our Registration Site or check out our Event Website for information on the area, parking, etc.
Thank you and we look forward to seeing you there.
|
| |
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
|
|
Locked
Re: Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ
Is there any possibility this will be recorded and/or streamed?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Mon, Aug 20, 2018 at 2:24 PM Annie Fisher < afisher@...> wrote: Greetings Tianji,
Thank you for your email. We'd love to have you at the event and have fixed the registration page, so please register now for the event.
Cheers, Annie Annie Fisher, MPA CSM
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
Hello, I am Tianji Jiang from the China Mobile Research, located in Milpitas, CA. Our team have been doing R&D on the edge-computing area and closely watching the progress of the AKRAINO project. I just learned this meeting scheduled in AT&T lab on this coming Thursday/Friday (08/23, 08/24) from my colleague in China Mobile. I am very interested and want to attend the meeting. However, when I went to the registration website, it is showing the registration is full currently. So, I am directly writing this email to your attention and hope you could help me register for the meeting. As you may know, as the largest mobile provider in the world (close to ~ 930 Million subscribers), we China Mobile are very committed to the edge-computing. Further, my colleagues have attended the AKRAINO meeting scheduled in Oregon Intel campus in this past May (2018/05). One of my team mates has registered for this week’s AKRAINO meeting in AT&T, and we want to attend together. Both of us are in the Silicon Valley and actively working in the edge-computing area. Given the more popularity and attraction of the AKRAINO project in edge-computing, we want to explore further the progress of the project so that we can participate more actively in the community. Thank you in advance for the registration help. Regards, -Tianji From: Jiajin Gao <jiajingao@...> Date: Monday, August 20, 2018 at 11:53 AM To: 'Tianji Jiang' <tianjijiang@...> Subject: FW: [akraino] Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ FYI. From: main@... [mailto:main@...] On Behalf Of Annie Fisher Sent: Tuesday, August 07, 2018 5:10 PM To: main@... Subject: [akraino] Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ 
Greetings,
Join us for a technical community discussion of the Akraino Edge Stack Project. This 1.5 day event will feature sessions on blueprints, seed code, architecture and more. Don't miss the opportunity to meet with fellow community members and help define the project roadmap!
Event Details: Akraino Edge Stack Project Developer Summit Date: Thursday, August 23rd, registration starting at 8:00 a.m., Friday, August 24th, half day (full schedule to follow) Where: AT&T Labs Research, Building A, 200 Laurel Avenue South, Middletown, New Jersey, 07748
PLEASE NOTE: Registration is limited to 5 participants per company.
To Register: Please visit our Registration Site or check out our Event Website for information on the area, parking, etc.
Thank you and we look forward to seeing you there.
|
| |
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
--
Kind regards,
Melvin Hillsman
|
|
Locked
Re: Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ
Annie Fisher <afisher@...>
Greetings Melvin,
Thank you for your email. We are working with the site team to record the sessions and possibly have a dial-in option. We will send out this information tomorrow, if possible.
Regardless, all decks will be collected and distributed after the event.
Cheers, Anne Annie Fisher, MPA CSM
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Mon, Aug 20, 2018 at 12:31 PM Melvin Hillsman < mrhillsman@...> wrote: Is there any possibility this will be recorded and/or streamed? On Mon, Aug 20, 2018 at 2:24 PM Annie Fisher < afisher@...> wrote: Greetings Tianji,
Thank you for your email. We'd love to have you at the event and have fixed the registration page, so please register now for the event.
Cheers, Annie Annie Fisher, MPA CSM
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
Hello, I am Tianji Jiang from the China Mobile Research, located in Milpitas, CA. Our team have been doing R&D on the edge-computing area and closely watching the progress of the AKRAINO project. I just learned this meeting scheduled in AT&T lab on this coming Thursday/Friday (08/23, 08/24) from my colleague in China Mobile. I am very interested and want to attend the meeting. However, when I went to the registration website, it is showing the registration is full currently. So, I am directly writing this email to your attention and hope you could help me register for the meeting. As you may know, as the largest mobile provider in the world (close to ~ 930 Million subscribers), we China Mobile are very committed to the edge-computing. Further, my colleagues have attended the AKRAINO meeting scheduled in Oregon Intel campus in this past May (2018/05). One of my team mates has registered for this week’s AKRAINO meeting in AT&T, and we want to attend together. Both of us are in the Silicon Valley and actively working in the edge-computing area. Given the more popularity and attraction of the AKRAINO project in edge-computing, we want to explore further the progress of the project so that we can participate more actively in the community. Thank you in advance for the registration help. Regards, -Tianji From: Jiajin Gao <jiajingao@...> Date: Monday, August 20, 2018 at 11:53 AM To: 'Tianji Jiang' <tianjijiang@...> Subject: FW: [akraino] Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ FYI. From: main@... [mailto:main@...] On Behalf Of Annie Fisher Sent: Tuesday, August 07, 2018 5:10 PM To: main@... Subject: [akraino] Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ 
Greetings,
Join us for a technical community discussion of the Akraino Edge Stack Project. This 1.5 day event will feature sessions on blueprints, seed code, architecture and more. Don't miss the opportunity to meet with fellow community members and help define the project roadmap!
Event Details: Akraino Edge Stack Project Developer Summit Date: Thursday, August 23rd, registration starting at 8:00 a.m., Friday, August 24th, half day (full schedule to follow) Where: AT&T Labs Research, Building A, 200 Laurel Avenue South, Middletown, New Jersey, 07748
PLEASE NOTE: Registration is limited to 5 participants per company.
To Register: Please visit our Registration Site or check out our Event Website for information on the area, parking, etc.
Thank you and we look forward to seeing you there.
|
| |
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
--
Kind regards,
Melvin Hillsman
|
|
Locked
Re: Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ
Ponnath, Krishna (Nokia - US/Plano)
Thanks a lot . Really looking forward to the dial in option.
Krishna
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
From: main@... <main@...>
On Behalf Of Annie Fisher
Sent: Monday, August 20, 2018 2:34 PM
To: main@...
Cc: tianjijiang@...
Subject: Re: [akraino] Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ
Greetings Melvin,
Thank you for your email. We are working with the site team to record the sessions and possibly have a dial-in option. We will send out this information tomorrow, if possible.
Regardless, all decks will be collected and distributed after the event.
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation
Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
On Mon, Aug 20, 2018 at 12:31 PM Melvin Hillsman <mrhillsman@...> wrote:
Is there any possibility this will be recorded and/or streamed?
On Mon, Aug 20, 2018 at 2:24 PM Annie Fisher <afisher@...> wrote:
Greetings Tianji,
Thank you for your email. We'd love to have you at the event and have fixed the registration page, so please register now for the event.
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation
Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
Hello,
I am Tianji Jiang from the China Mobile Research, located in Milpitas, CA. Our team have been doing R&D on the edge-computing area and closely watching the progress of the AKRAINO
project. I just learned this meeting scheduled in AT&T lab on this coming Thursday/Friday (08/23, 08/24) from my colleague in China Mobile. I am very interested and want to attend the meeting. However, when I went to the registration website, it is showing
the registration is full currently. So, I am directly writing this email to your attention and hope you could help me register for the meeting.
As you may know, as the largest mobile provider in the world (close to ~ 930 Million subscribers), we China Mobile are very committed to the edge-computing. Further, my colleagues
have attended the AKRAINO meeting scheduled in Oregon Intel campus in this past May (2018/05). One of my team mates has registered for this week’s AKRAINO meeting in AT&T, and we want to attend together. Both of us are in the Silicon Valley and actively working
in the edge-computing area. Given the more popularity and attraction of the AKRAINO project in edge-computing, we want to explore further the progress of the project so that we can participate more actively in the community.
Thank you in advance for the registration help.
Regards,
-Tianji
From:
Jiajin Gao <jiajingao@...>
Date: Monday, August 20, 2018 at 11:53 AM
To: 'Tianji Jiang' <tianjijiang@...>
Subject: FW: [akraino] Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ
FYI.
From:
main@... [mailto:main@...]
On Behalf Of Annie Fisher
Sent: Tuesday, August 07, 2018 5:10 PM
To: main@...
Subject: [akraino] Invitation: Akraino Edge Stack Developer Summit // August 23-34 // Middleton, NJ

Greetings,
Join us for a technical community discussion of the Akraino Edge Stack Project. This 1.5
day event will feature sessions on blueprints, seed code, architecture and more. Don't miss the opportunity to meet with fellow community members and help define the project roadmap!
Event Details: Akraino Edge Stack Project Developer Summit
Date: Thursday, August 23rd, registration starting at 8:00 a.m., Friday, August 24th, half day (full schedule to follow)
Where: AT&T Labs Research, Building A, 200
Laurel Avenue South, Middletown, New Jersey, 07748
PLEASE NOTE: Registration is limited to 5 participants per company.
To Register: Please visit our Registration Site or check out our Event
Website for information on the area, parking, etc.
Thank you and we look forward to seeing you there.
|
|
|
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation
Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
--
Kind regards,
Melvin Hillsman
|
|
Locked
Akraino Edge Stack: Remote access for Day 1
Annie Fisher <afisher@...>
Greetings all,
We'd like to thank AT&T for making arrangements for remote access for DAY 1 of the Arkraino Edge Stack Developer Summit.
PLEASE NOTE: Remote access will NOT be available for Day 2. All slide decks from all sessions will be available on the wiki shortly following the event.
Please utilize the following options for access and you'll find the agenda for the day attached.
Programming will begin at 8:45 a.m. with the Welcome Address by Arpit Joshipura, General Manager, Linux Foundation.
Join from PC, Mac, Linux, iOS or Android: https://zoom.us/j/928744900
Or iPhone one-tap : US: +16465588656,,928744900# or +16699006833,,928744900#
Or Telephone: Dial(for higher quality, dial a number based on your current location): US: +1 646 558 8656 or +1 669 900 6833 or +1 855 880 1246 (Toll Free) or +1 877 369 0926 (Toll Free) Meeting ID: 928 744 900
Annie Fisher, MPA CSM
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
|
|
Locked
Akraino Edge Stack: Availability of Slides from Presentations
Annie Fisher <afisher@...>
Greetings all,
Reminder: You will need your LF ID to log-in to the Arkaino Wiki. If you need to create and LF ID or need help in retrieving your password, please find the directions to do so below:
Creating a Linux Foundation ID:
- Go to the Linux Foundation ID website or https://identity.linuxfoundation.org/
- Select the option I need to create a Linux Foundation ID.
- Fill out the form that appears
- Open your email account and look for a message with the subject line: “Validate your Linux Foundation ID email”.
- Open the received URL to validate your email address.
- Verify the browser displays the message You have successfully validated your e-mail address.
If you do not know your password, or if you do not have a password because you created your account by clicking on the Google, Facebook, or Github buttons, you must reset your password. To reset your password, visit https://identity.linuxfoundation.org/ and ensure you are logged out. Then, click “Request n
Annie Fisher, MPA CSM
Program Manager, The Linux Foundation Location & Time-zone: San Francisco, CA, PT
|
|
Hi Akraino TSC,
In the last developer conference, TSC has taken an AI to come out with the Akraino charter definition.
Much of the discussion on last developer conference is mostly about blueprints, except for one break-out session.
In regional orchestration, Edge API and AI breakout session, we talked about the need for them and the consensus is that Akraino project is the right place to develop them. In one of the Kandan’s presentation, it was clear that Akraino
is not only for developing blueprints for various use cases, but is also a home for Edge related open source projects for the functionality where there is a gap in the open source community. Please consider making the Akraino charter clear on the aspect of
development projects to avoid any confusion.
Thanks
Srini
|
|
Wenjing Chu <Wenjing.Chu@...>
Very good point. We do need to clarify this as soon as possible.
In the initial draft on blueprints, I proposed that we (a) use “project” as a unit for all the development work in Akraino, and (b) categorize projects into 2 types: functional projects and blueprint integration
projects. (b) is similar to what Kandan called “vertical” and “horizontal”, but uses terms closer to those in other communities.
-
Functional projects develop functionalities to fill identified gaps.
-
Integration projects are responsible to deliver end-to-end ‘blueprints’. Integration projects can utilize the outputs of functional projects, and all upstream open source projects.
Wenjing
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
From: main@... [mailto:main@...]
On Behalf Of Srini
Sent: Tuesday, September 04, 2018 9:50 AM
To: main@...
Subject: [akraino] Akraino Charter
Hi Akraino TSC,
In the last developer conference, TSC has taken an AI to come out with the Akraino charter definition.
Much of the discussion on last developer conference is mostly about blueprints, except for one break-out session.
In regional orchestration, Edge API and AI breakout session, we talked about the need for them and the consensus is that Akraino project is the right place to develop them. In one of the Kandan’s presentation, it was clear that Akraino
is not only for developing blueprints for various use cases, but is also a home for Edge related open source projects for the functionality where there is a gap in the open source community. Please consider making the Akraino charter clear on the aspect of
development projects to avoid any confusion.
Thanks
Srini
|
|
On 09/04/2018 12:49 PM, Srini wrote:
Hi Akraino TSC,
In the last developer conference, TSC has
taken an AI to come out with the Akraino charter definition.
Much of the discussion on last developer
conference is mostly about blueprints, except for one
break-out session.
In regional orchestration, Edge API and AI
breakout session, we talked about the need for them and the
consensus is that Akraino project is the right place to
develop them.
It is not clear at all whether Akraino is the right owner for the
APIs or not --- many other projects and communities are working on
addressing the pieces of this rather large & diverse puzzle
(ONAP, CNCF/k8s, various projects in OPNFV & OpenStack, etc.
etc.), and IMHO, the last think that we need is more duplication for
the ongoing efforts which would result in even more fragmentation of
the landscape.
So, whenever possible, optimally Akraino would pull from
upstreams like OPNFV does and identify/address the gaps. Obviously
in the cases where there is nothing (or existing approaches are
deemed unsuitable / unfixable after careful consideration),
Akraino could be in good position to resolve.
I am saying the above, as ownership of the APIs does and should
belong to the projects implementing them, not something like
Akraino. If it is identifying, selecting and requesting additions
/ modifications, or Akraino hosted development projects, then that
would be ok. Blueprint for the infrastructure is expected to make
some selections for the projects that go in, so that implicitly
makes some picks on the APIs as well - but that would not make
Akraino "developer" for such cases, more like Endorser / selector.
That said, there is very much confusion between the ONAP edge as
well as Akraino (on both sides) on who is going to do what and
when which should get resolved sooner rather than later, as the
context of the comment was "regional orchestration".
Pasi
In one of the Kandan’s presentation, it was
clear that Akraino is not only for developing blueprints for
various use cases, but is also a home for Edge related open
source projects for the functionality where there is a gap in
the open source community. Please consider making the Akraino
charter clear on the aspect of development projects to avoid
any confusion.
Thanks
Srini
|
|
Very good point. We do need to clarify this as soon as possible.
In the initial draft on blueprints, I proposed that we (a) use “project” as a unit for all the development work in Akraino, and (b) categorize projects into 2 types: functional projects and blueprint integration
projects. (b) is similar to what Kandan called “vertical” and “horizontal”, but uses terms closer to those in other communities.
-
Functional projects develop functionalities to fill identified gaps.
Why wouldn't you do a blueprint for those too - perhaps a shorter blue print?
--Tom
-
Integration projects are responsible to deliver end-to-end ‘blueprints’. Integration projects can utilize the outputs of functional projects, and all upstream open source projects.
Wenjing
From: main@... [mailto:main@...]
On Behalf Of Srini
Sent: Tuesday, September 04, 2018 9:50 AM
To: main@...
Subject: [akraino] Akraino Charter
Hi Akraino TSC,
In the last developer conference, TSC has taken an AI to come out with the Akraino charter definition.
Much of the discussion on last developer conference is mostly about blueprints, except for one break-out session.
In regional orchestration, Edge API and AI breakout session, we talked about the need for them and the consensus is that Akraino project is the right place to develop them. In one of the Kandan’s presentation, it was clear that Akraino
is not only for developing blueprints for various use cases, but is also a home for Edge related open source projects for the functionality where there is a gap in the open source community. Please consider making the Akraino charter clear on the aspect of
development projects to avoid any confusion.
Thanks
Srini
|
|
Wenjing Chu <Wenjing.Chu@...>
As long as we agree that such work should take place in Akraino, then it’s just naming. Yes, we could have a “non-integration blueprint”, but it seems really
confusing to me.
Wenjing
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
From: main@... [mailto:main@...]
On Behalf Of Thomas Nadeau
Sent: Tuesday, September 04, 2018 1:34 PM
To: main@...
Subject: Re: [akraino] Akraino Charter
Very good point. We do need to clarify this as soon as possible.
In the initial draft on blueprints, I proposed that we (a) use “project” as a unit for all the development work in Akraino, and (b) categorize projects
into 2 types: functional projects and blueprint integration projects. (b) is similar to what Kandan called “vertical” and “horizontal”, but uses terms closer to those in other communities.
-
Functional projects develop functionalities to fill identified gaps.
Why wouldn't you do a blueprint for those too - perhaps a shorter blue print?
-
Integration projects are responsible to deliver end-to-end ‘blueprints’. Integration projects can utilize the outputs of functional projects, and all upstream open source projects.
Wenjing
From:
main@... [mailto:main@...]
On Behalf Of Srini
Sent: Tuesday, September 04, 2018 9:50 AM
To: main@...
Subject: [akraino] Akraino Charter
Hi Akraino TSC,
In the last developer conference, TSC has taken an AI to come out with the Akraino charter definition.
Much of the discussion on last developer conference is mostly about blueprints, except for one break-out session.
In regional orchestration, Edge API and AI breakout session, we talked about the need for them and the consensus is that Akraino project is the right place to develop them. In
one of the Kandan’s presentation, it was clear that Akraino is not only for developing blueprints for various use cases, but is also a home for Edge related open source projects for the functionality where there is a gap in the open source community. Please
consider making the Akraino charter clear on the aspect of development projects to avoid any confusion.
Thanks
Srini
|
|
The idea for doing everything in blueprints is that it brings visibility into any work that impacts the project to both the TSC, but also clearly in writing so any others (i.e.: integration, testing, etc...) that might be external to the project have clear information about what is planned or underway. On a related note, I view blue prints as being largely analogous to epics, and in the same way are a good way to plan for a current or future release, and just a good way to organize the moving parts of a large project like this one potentially can turn out to be.
--Tom
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
As long as we agree that such work should take place in Akraino, then it’s just naming. Yes, we could have a “non-integration blueprint”, but it seems really
confusing to me.
Wenjing
From: main@... [mailto:main@...]
On Behalf Of Thomas Nadeau
Sent: Tuesday, September 04, 2018 1:34 PM
To: main@...
Subject: Re: [akraino] Akraino Charter
Very good point. We do need to clarify this as soon as possible.
In the initial draft on blueprints, I proposed that we (a) use “project” as a unit for all the development work in Akraino, and (b) categorize projects
into 2 types: functional projects and blueprint integration projects. (b) is similar to what Kandan called “vertical” and “horizontal”, but uses terms closer to those in other communities.
-
Functional projects develop functionalities to fill identified gaps.
Why wouldn't you do a blueprint for those too - perhaps a shorter blue print?
-
Integration projects are responsible to deliver end-to-end ‘blueprints’. Integration projects can utilize the outputs of functional projects, and all upstream open source projects.
Wenjing
From:
main@... [mailto:main@...]
On Behalf Of Srini
Sent: Tuesday, September 04, 2018 9:50 AM
To: main@...
Subject: [akraino] Akraino Charter
Hi Akraino TSC,
In the last developer conference, TSC has taken an AI to come out with the Akraino charter definition.
Much of the discussion on last developer conference is mostly about blueprints, except for one break-out session.
In regional orchestration, Edge API and AI breakout session, we talked about the need for them and the consensus is that Akraino project is the right place to develop them. In
one of the Kandan’s presentation, it was clear that Akraino is not only for developing blueprints for various use cases, but is also a home for Edge related open source projects for the functionality where there is a gap in the open source community. Please
consider making the Akraino charter clear on the aspect of development projects to avoid any confusion.
Thanks
Srini
|
|
Wenjing Chu <Wenjing.Chu@...>
Visibility is the same whether we call it project or blueprint. I’m fine with either name.
Do note that if blueprint A and blueprint B share a component developed within Akraino, we will then need to create another blueprint C, as you suggested, and A and B would have dependency on C.
The key point here that Srini brought up is that we explicitly state that functionality development is in scope for Akraino.
Wenjing
From: Thomas Nadeau
Subject: Re: [akraino] Akraino Charter
Time: 2018-09-05 08:00:05
The idea for doing everything in blueprints is that it brings visibility into any work that impacts the project to both the TSC, but also clearly in writing so any others (i.e.: integration, testing, etc...) that might be external to the project
have clear information about what is planned or underway. On a related note, I view blue prints as being largely analogous to epics, and in the same way are a good way to plan for a current or future release, and just a good way to organize the moving parts
of a large project like this one potentially can turn out to be.
--Tom
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
As long as we agree that such work should take place in Akraino, then it’s just naming. Yes, we could have a “non-integration blueprint”, but it seems really
confusing to me.
Wenjing
From:
main@... [mailto:main@...]
On Behalf Of Thomas Nadeau
Sent: Tuesday, September 04, 2018 1:34 PM
To: main@...
Subject: Re: [akraino] Akraino Charter
Very good point. We do need to clarify this as soon as possible.
In the initial draft on blueprints, I proposed that we (a) use “project” as a unit for all the development work in Akraino, and (b) categorize projects into 2 types: functional projects and blueprint integration
projects. (b) is similar to what Kandan called “vertical” and “horizontal”, but uses terms closer to those in other communities.
-
Functional projects develop functionalities to fill identified gaps.
Why wouldn't you do a blueprint for those too - perhaps a shorter blue print?
-
Integration projects are responsible to deliver end-to-end ‘blueprints’. Integration projects can utilize the outputs of functional projects, and all upstream open source projects.
Wenjing
From:
main@... [mailto:main@...]
On Behalf Of Srini
Sent: Tuesday, September 04, 2018 9:50 AM
To: main@...
Subject: [akraino] Akraino Charter
Hi Akraino TSC,
In the last developer conference, TSC has taken an AI to come out with the Akraino charter definition.
Much of the discussion on last developer conference is mostly about blueprints, except for one break-out session.
In regional orchestration, Edge API and AI breakout session, we talked about the need for them and the consensus is that Akraino project is the right place to develop them. In one of the Kandan’s presentation, it was clear that Akraino
is not only for developing blueprints for various use cases, but is also a home for Edge related open source projects for the functionality where there is a gap in the open source community. Please consider making the Akraino charter clear on the aspect of
development projects to avoid any confusion.
Thanks
Srini
|
|
Cool. I think we are all on the same page now.
--Tom
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Visibility is the same whether we call it project or blueprint. I’m fine with either name.
Do note that if blueprint A and blueprint B share a component developed within Akraino, we will then need to create another blueprint C, as you suggested, and A and B would have dependency on C.
The key point here that Srini brought up is that we explicitly state that functionality development is in scope for Akraino.
Wenjing
From: Thomas Nadeau
Subject: Re: [akraino] Akraino Charter
Time: 2018-09-05 08:00:05
The idea for doing everything in blueprints is that it brings visibility into any work that impacts the project to both the TSC, but also clearly in writing so any others (i.e.: integration, testing, etc...) that might be external to the project
have clear information about what is planned or underway. On a related note, I view blue prints as being largely analogous to epics, and in the same way are a good way to plan for a current or future release, and just a good way to organize the moving parts
of a large project like this one potentially can turn out to be.
--Tom
As long as we agree that such work should take place in Akraino, then it’s just naming. Yes, we could have a “non-integration blueprint”, but it seems really
confusing to me.
Wenjing
From:
main@... [mailto:main@...]
On Behalf Of Thomas Nadeau
Sent: Tuesday, September 04, 2018 1:34 PM
To: main@...
Subject: Re: [akraino] Akraino Charter
Very good point. We do need to clarify this as soon as possible.
In the initial draft on blueprints, I proposed that we (a) use “project” as a unit for all the development work in Akraino, and (b) categorize projects into 2 types: functional projects and blueprint integration
projects. (b) is similar to what Kandan called “vertical” and “horizontal”, but uses terms closer to those in other communities.
-
Functional projects develop functionalities to fill identified gaps.
Why wouldn't you do a blueprint for those too - perhaps a shorter blue print?
-
Integration projects are responsible to deliver end-to-end ‘blueprints’. Integration projects can utilize the outputs of functional projects, and all upstream open source projects.
Wenjing
From:
main@... [mailto:main@...]
On Behalf Of Srini
Sent: Tuesday, September 04, 2018 9:50 AM
To: main@...
Subject: [akraino] Akraino Charter
Hi Akraino TSC,
In the last developer conference, TSC has taken an AI to come out with the Akraino charter definition.
Much of the discussion on last developer conference is mostly about blueprints, except for one break-out session.
In regional orchestration, Edge API and AI breakout session, we talked about the need for them and the consensus is that Akraino project is the right place to develop them. In one of the Kandan’s presentation, it was clear that Akraino
is not only for developing blueprints for various use cases, but is also a home for Edge related open source projects for the functionality where there is a gap in the open source community. Please consider making the Akraino charter clear on the aspect of
development projects to avoid any confusion.
Thanks
Srini
|
|
Locked
Akraino community call on Thursday September 6 11-12 Eastern Time
Tapio Tallgren <tapio.tallgren@...>
Hi all, Similar to other open source projects, Akraino will have a regular community call where members of the developer community can discuss issues in more depth than what can be done in for example the Technical Steering Committee (TSC) calls. The very first call be on Thursday, September 6th, starting at 11 Eastern Time. The topics in the community call will vary depending on the ongoing discussions in the mailing lists. For this first event, I can give a summary of the developer event and give an overview on the governance documents that the TSC is working on. A discussion topic is blueprints and horizontal projects -- these may not be the final names. Link to the event is: https://wiki.akraino.org/display/AK/Technical+CommunityWelcome to join!
|
|
Locked
Re: Akraino community call on Thursday September 6 11-12 Eastern Time
Margaret Chiosi <margaret.chiosi1@...>
Is this the weekly call set?
Thank You, Margaret Chiosi VP Open Ecosystem Team
Admin: Sophie Johnson Sophie.johnson1@... +1 (908) 541-3590
Futurewei Technologies, Inc. Fixed Network Solution CC 400 Crossing Blvd Bridgewater, NJ 08807 (cell) +1-732-216-5507
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
-----Original Message----- From: main@... [mailto:main@...] On Behalf Of Tapio Tallgren Sent: Wednesday, September 05, 2018 3:34 PM To: main@... Subject: [akraino] Akraino community call on Thursday September 6 11-12 Eastern Time Hi all, Similar to other open source projects, Akraino will have a regular community call where members of the developer community can discuss issues in more depth than what can be done in for example the Technical Steering Committee (TSC) calls. The very first call be on Thursday, September 6th, starting at 11 Eastern Time. The topics in the community call will vary depending on the ongoing discussions in the mailing lists. For this first event, I can give a summary of the developer event and give an overview on the governance documents that the TSC is working on. A discussion topic is blueprints and horizontal projects -- these may not be the final names. Link to the event is: https://wiki.akraino.org/display/AK/Technical+CommunityWelcome to join!
|
|
Locked
Re: Akraino community call on Thursday September 6 11-12 Eastern Time
Tapio Tallgren <tapio.tallgren@...>
Yes, the idea is that this would be a weekly call.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
From: main@... <main@...> on behalf of Margaret Chiosi <margaret.chiosi1@...>
Sent: Wednesday, September 5, 2018 11:00:41 PM
To: main@...
Subject: Re: [akraino] Akraino community call on Thursday September 6 11-12 Eastern Time
Is this the weekly call set?
Thank You,
Margaret Chiosi
VP Open Ecosystem Team
Admin: Sophie Johnson
Sophie.johnson1@...
+1 (908) 541-3590
Futurewei Technologies, Inc.
Fixed Network Solution CC
400 Crossing Blvd
Bridgewater, NJ 08807
(cell) +1-732-216-5507
-----Original Message-----
From: main@... [ mailto:main@...] On Behalf Of Tapio Tallgren
Sent: Wednesday, September 05, 2018 3:34 PM
To: main@...
Subject: [akraino] Akraino community call on Thursday September 6 11-12 Eastern Time
Hi all,
Similar to other open source projects, Akraino will have a regular community call where members of the developer community can discuss issues in more depth than what can be done in for example the Technical Steering Committee (TSC) calls. The very first call
be on Thursday, September 6th, starting at 11 Eastern Time.
The topics in the community call will vary depending on the ongoing discussions in the mailing lists. For this first event, I can give a summary of the developer event and give an overview on the governance documents that the TSC is working on. A discussion
topic is blueprints and horizontal projects -- these may not be the final names.
Link to the event is:
https://wiki.akraino.org/display/AK/Technical+Community
Welcome to join!
|
|